YouTube Yanks Coldplay/Satriani Videos

Joe Satriani accused Coldplay of plagiarism for lifting elements of his song "If I Could Fly" for its hit song "Viva La Vida" earlier this year.

Now, videos depicting similarities between the songs are disappearing from YouTube courtesy of Coldplay's label, EMI, which claims the videos infringe on its copyright. We found one that's still online, which you can see below for the time being.

You can still hear the Coldplay song elsewhere on YouTube, including in user-generated videos, so it seems likely that EMI is removing the comparison videos due to embarrassment on the part of Coldplay and/or legal ramifications for the ongoing Satriani suit, as Music Industry Blog posits. One imagines that a judge or jury would merely need to see one of these videos to conclude that there's a striking similarity between the songs... probably too striking.

It's conceivable that the Chris Martin lifted the beat, chords and melody from Satriani subconsciously. It's not uncommon for musicians to hear something and regurgitate it later without realizing it. Coldplay has been accused of stealing someone's music before -- for the same song, no less. And another YouTube video has cast doubt on these claims by showing that all three bands could owe a debt to some guy called Günther.

We're not so interested in the spat between Satriani and Martin; plagiarism accusations abound in the music world. What's interesting here is EMI using copyright as a way to remove one version of a Coldplay song while allowing other versions to remain online. It's a useful reminder of the ways in which copyright law can be used for purposes other than thwarting the infringement of copyright. In this case, it's a somewhat useful tool for downplaying plagiarism accusations directed at one of the world's top acts.

Many labels have deals with YouTube that allow their works to appear in user-generated videos, because doing so can net them more of YouTube's ad revenue (artists and labels sometimes can get paid when someone synchs their music to user-created video on YouTube). Apparently, these deals involve the ability to pull certain objectionable usages for reasons other than copyright, although the message that appears on YouTube -- "This video is no longer available due to a copyright claim by EMI Music" -- appears a bit disingenuous. If copyright were the issue, a YouTube search for "coldplay viva la vida" wouldn't return 32,700 results.