Sign In
SHARE
Smut-free Broadband: Like That's Gonna Happen
Kevin Maney rolls his eyes: OK, so, FCC Chairman Kevin Martin earlier this year said he wants to auction off a chunk of spectrum to someone who will build a nationwide wireless broadband service that would be free. Oh, and it would also have to have built-in content filters that would block pornography. And now, two Congressional Democrats -- Ed Markey and Anna Eshoo -- have sent an encouraging letter to the FCC.
What the --?
Of course it's a nice idea, just like utopian communism started out as a nice idea, except for the fact that things just don't work that way. A whole bunch of real businesses rely on actually charging for the wireless broadband services they provide. The government can't go around sanctioning free broadband any more than it can build a free electrical grid or a free airline. (It CAN offer the equivalent of food stamps for broadband to low-income people who qualify -- wouldn't that be a better way of getting broadband to people who can't afford it?)
But then -- this part about content filters is nothing but a political hand grenade. You throw it out there, and if you're a politician and you don't back it, you wind up vulnerable to being labeled a sleaze who wants kids to see porno. There's just a little problem with free speech and civil liberties. What's the government going to block? Hustler.com? The Sports Illustrated swimsuit Web page? NBCOlympics videos of women volleyball players in tiny shorts? Who gets to decide? And when will the lawsuits from blocked sites and the ACLU start to pile up?
Anyway, the letter from Markey and Eshoo also mentions their WIN for Families Act, which is essentially the same as the FCC's idea. And not one that's likely to see the light of day.
Loading...
Thank you for registering as a Portfolio.com Insider. Your comment has been added.
Create Your Public Profile
- First Bytes: SEC Eyes Tweets, Waiting on a Verizon iPhone
- Apr 27 2009 9:10AM EDT
- Last Bytes: A New MySpaceFace, Technological Necessities
- Apr 24 2009 5:22PM EDT
- What the One Billionth Downloader Won
- Apr 24 2009 2:37PM EDT
- The End of Innocence at Apple
- Apr 24 2009 11:25AM EDT
- First Bytes: Social Videos, 1 Billion Apps, Mt. Everest Calls
- Apr 24 2009 10:23AM EDT
- Last Bytes: Microsoft and Amazon, Two Tales of the Economy
- Apr 23 2009 5:40PM EDT
- Dell's Plastic Surgery
- Apr 23 2009 3:12PM EDT
- Why High Tech Needs the Wall Street Quants
- Apr 23 2009 11:20AM EDT
- First Bytes: New Blood at MySpace, Steve Jobs Testimony
- Apr 23 2009 9:05AM EDT
- Last Bytes: Apple Profit Soars; eBay Profit Falls
- Apr 22 2009 5:04PM EDT
- Earth Day Special: Gadgets to Green Your Lifestyle
- Apr 22 2009 1:52PM EDT
- First Bytes: Cyberspies and Belgian Bots
- Apr 22 2009 9:55AM EDT
- Last Bytes: Is Texting Passé? Not Yet.
- Apr 21 2009 5:52PM EDT
- Happy 20th Birthday, Game Boy
- Apr 21 2009 4:11PM EDT
- Gaming Geeks (and Curt Schilling) Unite!
- Apr 21 2009 12:43PM EDT
Archive
Categories
Links
- Kevin Maney's site
- TechCrunch
- GigaOM
- Engadget
- USA TODAY Tech
- Romenesko
- BuzzTracker Tech
- Roger McGuinn's Folk Den
- Maney's band on MySpace
- Spiedies, mmmm
- Somewhat Frank's tech conference list
- Marc Andreessen
- Mark Cuban's blog
- Tom Foremski
- Fred Wilson
- Pandora
- SciTech Daily
- Todd Bishop's Microsoft Blog
- Steven Johnson
- The Long Tail
- paidContent
- John Battelle's SearchBlog
