Recent Blog Posts
-
Where the Tech World Gathers
Feb 10 20125:46 pm EDT -
Obama Blacklisted From Popular New App
Feb 09 20125:20 pm EDT -
Thermostat Startup Nest Comes Out Swinging
Feb 09 201211:46 am EDT -
Apps and Email, Together at Last
Feb 08 20124:30 pm EDT -
The Future Cemetery
Feb 08 201210:15 am EDT -
Open Letter to Congress on SOPA: Take a Breath
Feb 07 20121:00 pm EDT -
Greatest Generation Company Sues iPod Generation Startup Nest
Feb 06 20123:46 pm EDT -
Path Cuts Through Social-Media Noise
Feb 03 201212:10 pm EDT -
Gift Apps That Keep on Giving
Feb 01 20125:19 pm EDT -
A Proxy Piece of the Facebook Pie
Jan 31 20125:00 pm EDT
Links
- Engadget

- Pandora

- GigaOM

- USA TODAY Tech

- Somewhat Frank's tech conference list

- BuzzTracker Tech

- The Long Tail

- Tom Foremski

- Roger McGuinn's Folk Den

- John Battelle's SearchBlog

- Mark Cuban's blog

- SciTech Daily

- Romenesko

- Kevin Maney's site

- Steven Johnson

- Marc Andreessen

- TechCrunch

- Fred Wilson

- paidContent

- Spiedies, mmmm

- TechFlash

The Social Networking Orgy: What the ---- ?!
OK, we've got, like, a stinkin' bacchanal of social networking strategery going on today, and I don't know about you, but most of the time I don't have ANY idea what these companies are talking about or how I'll use what they're offering.
Google's got this Friend Connect thing. "Visitors to any site using Google Friend Connect will be able to see, invite, and interact with new friends, or, using secure authorization APIs, with existing friends from social sites on the web," its press release says.
Microsoft has a new service that will "allow users to watch video clips at the same time as a network of friends and chat via Windows Live Messenger."
Facebook on Friday said it will make its user profiles portable. "Users will be able to connect their Facebook account with any partner website using a trusted authentication method," the company said.
Ultimately, I get that the idea is that everyone can have one profile that they can use no matter what Web site they're on. No more forgetting to delete the photos of you with your previous girlfriend on Orkut.
And I get that every Web site should eventually seem "alive." You're shopping on Amazon, reading news here on Portolio.com, checking how much value your house has lost on Zillow -- wherever you are, you should be able to see if any of your friends from any social network are also there at the same time, and if so, chat with them. It should be the Web equivalent of being able to visually see someone you know coming toward you down the aisle at Home Depot.
BUT -- I read these news items and have two personal reactions.
1. These baby steps are painful and I don't know what each of them means, where I'll encounter them, or how I'll use them. They come across as a whole lot of tech nerd gibberish. And it is obvious that every company that's behind in social networking (Microsoft, Google, Yahoo) is throwing everything it can think of at the wall and hoping something sticks.
2. I don't believe that the ultimate solution of a single portable profile and open access to all your friends on any Web site will ever happen. If that was ever going to be possible, it would've happened by now with instant messaging -- and in a better way than the only way it's happening now: with outsider Meebo grafting the different IM networks into a single site.
How about we lock Facebook, MySpace, Microsoft and Google in a room and not let them come out with any press releases until they have a working system figured out.
. □
Comments
If you are commenting using a Facebook account, your profile information may be displayed with your comment depending on your privacy settings. By leaving the 'Post to Facebook' box selected, your comment will be published to your Facebook profile in addition to the space below.




