Dear Lou Reed: MP3s Won't Go Away
Lou Reed, owner of perhaps the most tuneless voice in rock music (which is more fact than criticism), whined at the SXSW conference about the quality of MP3 music. Indeed, MP3s are about 10 times worse fidelity than music on CDs. As Reed noted in his keynote speech, you can't hear the richness of the music. "People have got to demand a higher standard," he said.
But...most won't. It's a funny thing, recorded-music fidelity moving backward after a long march forward from the 1930s to the 1980s. But the mass market has traded high fidelity for good-enough fidelity and much greater convenience -- i.e., you can carry around your entire music collection in your pocket, and buy specific songs you want. We're not going to give up that convenience. Just look at the comment-revolt at Lifehacker when an editor suggested it was time to go back to buying CDs.

Jack Plunkett/AP Photo.
- Kennet Can, Raises $315 Million Fund
- Jul 24 2008 3:00AM EDT
- First Bytes: Microsoft, Facebook, San Fran Muni-Hacker Update
- Jul 24 2008 12:07AM EDT
- Last Bytes: Google, Amazon.com, San Fran Muni-Hacker Update...
- Jul 23 2008 6:26PM EDT
- Zuckerberg's Facebook F8 Keynote Cures Insomnia
- Jul 23 2008 6:09PM EDT
- Why iPhone Shows the Folly of the FCC Worrying About XM-Sirius
- Jul 23 2008 5:47PM EDT
- Tell Us You're Healthy, Steve Jobs
- Jul 23 2008 1:19PM EDT
- Questcor: From Orphan Drug To Orphan Stock?
- Jul 23 2008 12:48PM EDT
- Esquire, E-Ink: Future of Print?
- Jul 23 2008 10:58AM EDT
- Rocket Racing Debut: So What's That Carbon Footprint?
- Jul 23 2008 9:17AM EDT
- First Bytes: Yahoo, Digg Sale, Steve Jobs' Health, more....
- Jul 23 2008 9:01AM EDT
- Digg Stalled, Off to Google?
- Jul 23 2008 7:46AM EDT
- Last Bytes: Yahoo, Facebook, Apple, MySpace
- Jul 22 2008 6:13PM EDT
- Online Porn Saga
- Jul 22 2008 5:00PM EDT
- Forget Eyeballs, It's The Monetization, Stupid
- Jul 22 2008 2:45PM EDT
- First Bytes: Yahoo, Apple, TechCrunch, Amazon, Comcast
- Jul 22 2008 10:08AM EDT
Archive
Jul 2008
Categories
- Big Ideas
- Books
- Cellular Squabbles
- Commerce
- Controversy
- Daily Brew
- Dispatches From the Music Industry
- Dispatches From the Next Generation
- E3
- Fidelity vs. Convenience
- First Bytes
- Gadgets
- Gaming
- History
- Labs and Mad Scientists
- Last Bytes
- Music
- Power Supply
- Randomness
- Songs
- Tech Stars
- The Internet
- The Next Billion
- Venture Capital
- Widgets and Whatnot
- Wireless Wars
Links
- Mark Cuban's blog

- TechCrunch

- GigaOM

- Engadget

- USA TODAY Tech

- Romenesko

- BuzzTracker Tech

- Roger McGuinn's Folk Den

- Maney's band on MySpace

- Spiedies, mmmm

- Somewhat Frank's tech conference list

- Tom Foremski

- Fred Wilson

- Futurismic

- Pandora

- SciTech Daily

- Todd Bishop's Microsoft Blog

- Steven Johnson

- The Long Tail

- Howard Morgan's WayTooEarly

- paidContent

- John Battelle's SearchBlog

- Fake Steve

- Marc Andreessen

- Kevin's site





