Do Happiness and Economic Growth Rise, and Fall, Together?
For many years economists didn't think so.
In 1974, and again in 1995, Richard Easterlin, now of USC, famously showed that self-reported measures of happiness hadn't risen in Japan, Europe and the United States even after years of economic growth.
But more recent work has questioned that result, and now Betsey Stevenson and Justin Wolfers of Wharton have taken another crack at the data and found evidence that life satisfaction did in fact increase as the economy grew for both Europe and Japan. The United States remains the odd-nation out, however.
In the case of Japan, Stevenson and Wolfers found evidence that subjective well-being grew through 1992 but has since declined, coinciding with Japan's recession in the 1990's and slow recovery since.
As for the U.S., happiness was flat or may have actually declined between 1972 and 2006. The likely explanation for this is rising income inequality. This from NYT's David Leonhardt today:
Real median family income more than doubled from the late 1940s to the late '70s. It has risen less than 25 percent in the three decades since. Statistics like these are now so familiar as to be almost numbing. But the larger point is still crucial: the modern American economy distributes the fruits of its growth to a relatively narrow slice of the population.
This chart from Stevenson and Wolfers' paper, to be presented tomorrow at a Brooking Institute conference, shows how an index of happiness which was constructed by the pair has been relatively flat for the U.S. over the past 30+ years:

Turning their attention to less-developed countries, Stevenson and Wolfers found similar links between income growth and happiness. Interestingly, there also doesn't also appear to be a point at which more income doesn't go hand-in-hand with greater happiness:
We establish a clear positive link between GDP and average levels of subjective well-being across countries with no evidence of a satiation point beyond which wealthier countries have no further increases in subjective well-being.
While it's not true in every case -- for example, both Belgium and Ireland had declines in happiness as their economies grew -- the overall trend discovered by Stevenson and Wolfers seriously calls into question Easterlin's claim that "raising the incomes of all does not increase the happiness of all."
UPDATE
Easterlin responds. From the FT:
Prof Easterlin, who has seen a draft of the paper, said he believed that as far as he was concerned his paradox still stood.
While commending his younger critics for "serious research", he said they needed to focus more on what was happening within specific countries, rather than "throwing all of these countries together".
He sounded a bit more supportive in an email he sent me today:
It's good to see someone actually trying to study change over time, instead of just generalizing from cross sections.
- Chart of the Day: Baseball Ex-Steroids
- May 15 2008 1:26PM EDT
- Bubble Poppers
- May 14 2008 9:36PM EDT
- Quantifying Mortgage Fraud
- May 13 2008 6:32PM EDT
- Chart of the Day: The Worst Is Over
- May 13 2008 11:15AM EDT
- Is Text Messaging a Rip-Off?
- May 12 2008 5:37PM EDT
- Legalizing Insider Trading, With a Catch
- May 9 2008 5:34PM EDT
- Real Housewives of NYC -- A Lot of Them
- May 8 2008 7:10PM EDT
- When Envy Trumps Ambition
- May 7 2008 8:29AM EDT
- Achieving Universal Coverage at No Extra Cost
- May 1 2008 11:19AM EDT
- Gambling Strategies: Always Bet on White (Referees)
- Apr 30 2008 10:10PM EDT
- Unanswered Questions: To Pause or Not to Pause?
- Apr 30 2008 3:39PM EDT
- Grim Budget Outlook Forces Treasury to Bring Back 1-Year Bill
- Apr 30 2008 11:58AM EDT
- Does It Make Sense to Buy Forever Stamps?
- Apr 29 2008 9:58PM EDT
- When Jews and Christians Compete
- Apr 28 2008 10:05PM EDT
- Questioning the Link Between Commodity Wealth and Oppression
- Apr 25 2008 1:59PM EDT
Archive
May 2008
Categories
- advertising
- aging
- altruism
- art
- baseball
- basketball
- behavior
- books
- business cycles
- charts
- compensation
- crime
- derivatives
- drugs
- education
- elections
- ethics
- finance
- football
- foreign exchange
- gambling
- gender
- globalization
- golf
- growth
- happiness
- health care
- history
- incentives
- inequality
- interactive
- intolerance
- investing
- jobs
- marriage
- media
- monetary policy
- movies
- music
- obesity
- painting
- politics
- population
- prediction markets
- privacy
- psychology
- racism
- random
- real estate
- religion
- roundup
- sex
- spending
- sports
- taxes
- trade
- war
Links
- Email me

- Bluematter

- Decision Science News

- Economist's View

- EconTalk

- EconPapers

- Freakonomics

- Geary Behaviour Centre

- Institute for the Study of Labor

- Journal of Interest

- Marginal Revolution

- MoneyScience

- NBER Working Papers

- New York Federal Reserve Research

- Research Recap

- Social Science Research Network

- Social Science Statistics Blog

- Statistical Modeling, Causal Inference, and Social Science

- Unconventional Wisdom

- VoxEU





