Predictably Irrational
A pop quiz. Who wrote this:
"...these models do not fully capture what I believe has been, to date, only a peripheral addendum to... financial modelling - the innate human responses that result in swings between euphoria and fear that repeat themselves generation after generation with little evidence of a learning curve."
No, that's not Dan Ariely, but Alan Greenspan.
In a piece for the Financial Times which can only be read as a triumph for behavioral economics, the Maestro calls on forecasters to account for the fact that humans and markets don't always act with Reason on their side, especially during a downturn:
Asset-price bubbles build and burst today as they have since the early 18th century, when modern competitive markets evolved. To be sure, we tend to label such behavioral responses as non-rational. But forecasters' concerns should be not whether human response is rational or irrational, only that it is observable and systematic.
The observably irrational part of the current financial crisis came to light in August when some hedge funds unexpectedly faltered: Assets that had typically moved in different directions -- allowing for hedging opportunities which helped drive profits for many funds -- started to move together, implying that liquidity was drying up. As hedge fund losses stacked up, anxiety about greater losses down the line also mounted. The market had moved from a period of "euphoria" to a period of "fear."
What Greenspan argues is that this type of reaction shouldn't catch forecasters and policymakers so off-guard in the future. But is this behavior systematic? The bank runs of the Great Depression, the failure of Long-Term Capital Management, and the demise of Britain's Northern Rock suggest that it is.
It's worth remembering that Greenspan has been heavily influenced by Ayn Rand and her philosophy of rational self-interest, which has been used by more than a few Wall Streeters to justify their big paychecks -- at least until this year. Behavioral finance and rational self-interest have never been on friendly terms, but will the idea that irrational behavior is predictable bridge these two schools of thought?
Just last month, Steve Levitt and John List of the University of Chicago wrote that as neat as the findings of behavioral economics have been over the past two-and-a-half decades, their practical usefulness has remained marginal:
Perhaps the greatest challenge facing behavioral economics is demonstrating its applicability in the real world. In nearly every instance, the strongest empirical evidence in favor of behavioral anomalies emerges from the lab. Yet, there are many reasons to suspect that these laboratory findings might fail to generalize to real markets.
I'd like to add the financial collapse of 2007-08 as Exhibit A.
- Mortgage Fraud Redux
- May 16 2008 8:05PM EDT
- When Superpowers Prop Up Governments
- May 16 2008 4:40PM EDT
- Chart of the Day: Baseball Ex-Steroids
- May 15 2008 1:26PM EDT
- Bubble Poppers
- May 14 2008 9:36PM EDT
- Quantifying Mortgage Fraud
- May 13 2008 6:32PM EDT
- Chart of the Day: The Worst Is Over
- May 13 2008 11:15AM EDT
- Is Text Messaging a Rip-Off?
- May 12 2008 5:37PM EDT
- Legalizing Insider Trading, With a Catch
- May 9 2008 5:34PM EDT
- Real Housewives of NYC -- A Lot of Them
- May 8 2008 7:10PM EDT
- When Envy Trumps Ambition
- May 7 2008 8:29AM EDT
- Achieving Universal Coverage at No Extra Cost
- May 1 2008 11:19AM EDT
- Gambling Strategies: Always Bet on White (Referees)
- Apr 30 2008 10:10PM EDT
- Unanswered Questions: To Pause or Not to Pause?
- Apr 30 2008 3:39PM EDT
- Grim Budget Outlook Forces Treasury to Bring Back 1-Year Bill
- Apr 30 2008 11:58AM EDT
- Does It Make Sense to Buy Forever Stamps?
- Apr 29 2008 9:58PM EDT
Archive
May 2008
Categories
- advertising
- aging
- altruism
- art
- baseball
- basketball
- behavior
- books
- business cycles
- charts
- compensation
- crime
- derivatives
- drugs
- education
- elections
- ethics
- finance
- football
- foreign exchange
- gambling
- gender
- globalization
- golf
- growth
- happiness
- health care
- history
- incentives
- inequality
- interactive
- intolerance
- investing
- jobs
- marriage
- media
- monetary policy
- movies
- music
- obesity
- painting
- politics
- population
- prediction markets
- privacy
- psychology
- racism
- random
- real estate
- religion
- roundup
- sex
- spending
- sports
- taxes
- trade
- war
Links
- Email me

- Bluematter

- Decision Science News

- Economist's View

- EconTalk

- EconPapers

- Freakonomics

- Geary Behaviour Centre

- Institute for the Study of Labor

- Journal of Interest

- Marginal Revolution

- MoneyScience

- NBER Working Papers

- New York Federal Reserve Research

- Research Recap

- Social Science Research Network

- Social Science Statistics Blog

- Statistical Modeling, Causal Inference, and Social Science

- Unconventional Wisdom

- VoxEU





