The Penny Should Go, But What About the Nickel?
As the dollar plummets to new lows, the already limited purchasing power of the penny takes a whacking right along with it. The WSJ reports this morning that the dollar is at its lowest level since 1973 against a basket of currencies. Adjusting for inflation, a penny in 1973 is now worth $0.002 -- rounding off, the penny is practically worthless.
That line of thinking may have been behind Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson's comment on Friday that "the penny is worth less than any other currency." (At least let's hope so, because otherwise we'd have to promote him to Captain Obvious.)
Paulson also said it's time for the penny to go as the high cost of the zinc and copper that go into each penny have made it a losing proposition for the government for the past three years. At it's worst in 2006, it actually cost the U.S. Mint 1.75 cents to manufacture each one-cent penny. Given the fall in copper and zinc prices since then, it now costs about 1.2 cents to make each penny. With over 7 billion pennies manufactured in an average year, that's about $14 million of economic waste.
But the penny isn't the only coin in the red. The copper and nickel needed to produce a five-cent nickel cost 7 cents and with about 700 million made each year, that's another $14 million lost. (The dime and quarter are in much better shape.)
The case against getting rid of the penny was made by Penn State University economist Ray Lombra here and here. He argued that dumping the penny would result in a "rounding tax" that could cost consumers at least $600 million annually. That's because most prices end with a nine (such as $5.99) and without a one-cent coin these would get rounded up.
But that claim doesn't hold up when looking at real-world data, Wake Forest economist Robert Whaples countered. Examining 200,000 cash transactions at a convenience store chain, he found that when state and local taxes are factored in, there is no rounding error.
What about the nickel? Would there be a rounding tax if prices were listed at 10-cent intervals? My sense is yes, if only because there are more digits that would get rounded up than down (1-4 verus 5-9). But the role of taxes could apply here as well.
So what to do? In the past, when the cost of making a coin became too high relative to the actual value of the coin, the government has reconfigured the metals required to produce the coin -- as in the 1982 example above. The steep declines in this chart represent those times when the government rebased a coin.

(source)
But the penny has also become less and less relevant in the economy as both inflation and productivity gains make it less and less valuable:

So a good solution, borrowed from Federal Reserve economist Francois R. Velde, would be to send the one-cent coin the way of the half-cent coin, decree that all pennies in circulation are now worth five cents, and rebase the nickel so that it's made from cheaper metals.
This sort of change won't happen until at least after the elections, but it's likely only a matter of time before the nickel becomes the new penny. In fact, it already is: five cents in 1973 are now worth one cent.
Loading...
Thank you for registering as a Portfolio.com Insider. Your comment has been added.
Create Your Public Profile- The Year in Research
- Dec 31 2008 9:13AM EST
- Mind Your Value Judgements
- Dec 19 2008 7:52PM EST
- S.E.C. Short-Sale Ban: Pretty Much Useless
- Dec 19 2008 3:45PM EST
- Advice from Japan: Don't Forget TARP 1
- Dec 19 2008 2:31PM EST
- Chart of the Day: Money Market Stress Easing
- Dec 18 2008 8:57PM EST
- House Price Bubble Deflated?
- Dec 18 2008 5:57PM EST
- Where Were the Whistleblowers?
- Dec 16 2008 11:03PM EST
- It's Just a Recession
- Dec 13 2008 10:20PM EST
- Comparing American and European Unemployment Insurance
- Dec 12 2008 7:46PM EST
- Back to Normal?
- Dec 11 2008 4:33PM EST
- Chart of the Day: Japan Under Quantitative Easing
- Dec 10 2008 4:11PM EST
- Don't Cry for Capitalism
- Dec 9 2008 4:13PM EST
- Can We Remember the Pain of Bubbles Past?
- Dec 8 2008 4:58PM EST
- The Pain to Come
- Dec 5 2008 6:04PM EST
- The Lending Standards Red Herring
- Dec 4 2008 3:34PM EST
Categories
Links
- Email me

- Geary Behaviour Centre

- NBER Working Papers

- Social Science Statistics Blog

- Decision Science News

- Freakonomics

- New York Federal Reserve Research

- Statistical Modeling, Causal Inference, and Social Science

- Marginal Revolution

- EconTalk

- MoneyScience

- VoxEU

- Journal of Interest

- Bluematter

- Economist's View

- Research Recap

- Social Science Research Network

- Institute for the Study of Labor

- EconPapers

- Real Time Economics

- Center for Economic Policy Research

- B.I.S. Working Papers

- C.B.O. Director's Blog

- Federal Reserve Working Papers

- Institute for the Study of Labor

- O.E.C.D. Factblog

- Philadelphia Fed Research

- St. Louis Fed Research

- Sabernomics

- Sabermetric Research

- Economic Principals

- Numbers Guy

- Econbrowser

- STATS Blog

- Jeff Frankel

- Junk Charts

- Predictably/Irrational

- Tim Harford

- TierneyLab

- Curious Capitalist

- DataPoints: The Dismal Scientist Blog







