Beyond GDP
By the curious standard of the GDP, the nation's economic hero is a terminal cancer patient that is going through a costly divorce. The happiest event is an earthquake or a hurricane. The most desirable habitat is a multibillion-dollar Superfund site. All these add to GDP, because they cause money to change hands. It is as if a business kept a balance sheet by merely adding up all 'transactions", without distinguishing between income and expenses, or between assets and liabilities.(Source)
It's only fitting that on the day market-based principles failed spectacularly, French President Nikolas Sarkozy named Nobel winner Joseph Stiglitz of Columbia University to head a panel tasked with finding new measures of economic growth that will include non-monetary components.
As described in the quote above, the biggest criticisms against using Gross Domestic Product as a proxy for well-being is that it's solely based on market transactions.
So, taking an extreme imaginary example, if one year Brazil tore down the entire Amazon as inputs for products sold on the market, merely looking at the GDP figure for that year would lead someone to believe that the country was an economic powerhouse. But, of course, the damage done to the environment would mean that GDP would plummet the following year.
In other words:
GDP does not reflect the consumption of capital during the production process, and thus overestimates the value of output that actually contributes to well-being without lowering future production.(emphasis mine)
And what about happiness? Although recent research has shown that national income is correlated to feelings of well-being among countries of different income groups, it's less the case among countries of the same group. Robust GDP growth can also mask growing incoming inequality. (And let's not forget that housework is absent from GDP too.)
Stiglitz tells the AFP that any new indicators developed by his panel might not "be a replacement of current measures, but may be a construction of complementary measures."
There is no shortage of alternative GDP measures, but in order for them to be taken seriously they must try to marry market activity with measures of health, inequality, well-being, and environmental impact -- plus they should be comparable internationally.
So, as inspiration for Stiglitz's panel (which will also feature Nobel laureate Amartya Sen of India), and for the visually minded, here is a Venn diagram from Deutsche Bank research that illustrates what GDP measures, and what it doesn't (click to enlarge):
And here is a list of alternative GDP measures that are out there already (organization that developed it in parenthesis). For a review of their strengths and weaknesses, see here (the biggest weakness for measures that go beyond market transactions is finding a universally agreeable way to put values on environmental impact, well-being, etc.):
Intended to adjust GDP:
- Genuine Progress Indicator - tries to correct GDP by monetizing environmental and social factors (Redefining Progress)
- Green GDP in China - tries to correct GDP by monetizing environmental factors (Chinese Government)
- Genuine Savings - provides estimates for savings by considering environmental and social factors (World Bank)
Intended to replace GDP:
- Human Development Index - combines GDP with social indicators (UN)
- Carbon Footprint - measures the ecological pressure of humanity in the biosphere (WWF and Carbon Footprint Network)
- Happy Planet Index - Life satisfaction data combined with environmental footprint data (new economics foundation)
- Environmental Sustainability Index/Environmental Performance Index - Tracks a society's capacity to improve environmental performance (Yale, WEF)
- Regional Quality of Development Index - combines social, environmental and economic data (Sbilanciamoci!)
Intended to complement GDP:
- System of Economic Environmental Accounts - combines environmental and economic data (UN)
- German Environmental Economic Accounting - German version of the above (German Government)
- National Accounts Matrix including Environmental Accounts - keeps track of how inputs and outputs in GDP affect the environment (Netherlands Government)
- System of Economic and Social Accounting matrices and Extensions - Similar to above but includes social welfare measures (Netherlands Government)
Loading...
Thank you for registering as a Portfolio.com Insider. Your comment has been added.
Create Your Public Profile- The Year in Research
- Dec 31 2008 9:13AM EST
- Mind Your Value Judgements
- Dec 19 2008 7:52PM EST
- S.E.C. Short-Sale Ban: Pretty Much Useless
- Dec 19 2008 3:45PM EST
- Advice from Japan: Don't Forget TARP 1
- Dec 19 2008 2:31PM EST
- Chart of the Day: Money Market Stress Easing
- Dec 18 2008 8:57PM EST
- House Price Bubble Deflated?
- Dec 18 2008 5:57PM EST
- Where Were the Whistleblowers?
- Dec 16 2008 11:03PM EST
- It's Just a Recession
- Dec 13 2008 10:20PM EST
- Comparing American and European Unemployment Insurance
- Dec 12 2008 7:46PM EST
- Back to Normal?
- Dec 11 2008 4:33PM EST
- Chart of the Day: Japan Under Quantitative Easing
- Dec 10 2008 4:11PM EST
- Don't Cry for Capitalism
- Dec 9 2008 4:13PM EST
- Can We Remember the Pain of Bubbles Past?
- Dec 8 2008 4:58PM EST
- The Pain to Come
- Dec 5 2008 6:04PM EST
- The Lending Standards Red Herring
- Dec 4 2008 3:34PM EST
Categories
Links
- Email me

- Geary Behaviour Centre

- NBER Working Papers

- Social Science Statistics Blog

- Decision Science News

- Freakonomics

- New York Federal Reserve Research

- Statistical Modeling, Causal Inference, and Social Science

- Marginal Revolution

- EconTalk

- MoneyScience

- VoxEU

- Journal of Interest

- Bluematter

- Economist's View

- Research Recap

- Social Science Research Network

- Institute for the Study of Labor

- EconPapers

- Real Time Economics

- Center for Economic Policy Research

- B.I.S. Working Papers

- C.B.O. Director's Blog

- Federal Reserve Working Papers

- Institute for the Study of Labor

- O.E.C.D. Factblog

- Philadelphia Fed Research

- St. Louis Fed Research

- Sabernomics

- Sabermetric Research

- Economic Principals

- Numbers Guy

- Econbrowser

- STATS Blog

- Jeff Frankel

- Junk Charts

- Predictably/Irrational

- Tim Harford

- TierneyLab

- Curious Capitalist

- DataPoints: The Dismal Scientist Blog








