'NYT' on 'Atlantic' Deathwatch Story: 'Poor Analysis'

Not a Portfolio.com Insider?

In This Issue of Condé Nast Portfolio

Home > Views > Blogs > Mixed Media > 'NYT' on 'Atlantic' Deathwatch Story: 'Poor Analysis'

Your Name

Your Email Address *
Send a copy to me

Recipient's Email Address *

Separate multiple email addresses (max 20) with commas.

Subject *

Message

0/1500

Email Confirmation

Mixed Media

by Jeff Bercovici

Main

Late Breaks: Rethinking Deep Throat;... Idle Chatter: Presidential Sign-Off,...

Jan 12 2009 3:57PM EST

Guess who wasn't too happy about that Atlantic article saying The New York Times might go out of business in May?

Yup: The New York Times.

Michael Hirschorn's worst-case-scenario chin-stroker "may make for a good a story but it is poor analysis," says a Times spokeswoman in an open letter posted on Jim Romenesko's media blog. "People in the media industry are working extraordinarily hard to find creative solutions to the issues they face. It is a time for clear thinking and analysis, not uninformed speculation."

Of course, other, more disinterested critics have already pointed out some of the rather glaring flaws in Hirschorn's piece. The Times spokeswoman says they could have been avoided: "It's not unusual that a journalist calls the subject of a piece before actually publishing the article or column. In fact, in some areas of journalism that's standard practice. We wish that had happened with this story. We could have helped."

See more in

Newspapers

Add Your Comment

Already a Portfolio.com Insider? Sign In

Comments*

Thank you for registering as a Portfolio.com Insider. Your comment has been added.

Create Your Public Profile

Recent Blog Posts

Conde Nast Closing 'Portfolio'
Apr 27 2009 10:02AM EDT
Newspaper Circ: 'WSJ' Gains as 'NY Post' Tumbles
Apr 27 2009 9:32AM EDT
Idle Chatter: The Prognosis for Newspapers, more
Apr 27 2009 8:55AM EDT
Late Breaks: MySpace, NYT, 'New York'
Apr 24 2009 4:01PM EDT
Nostalgia, Entitlement and Murdoch's 'Journal'
Apr 24 2009 4:00PM EDT
Huffpo's Lerer on the 'New and Better' Journalism
Apr 24 2009 12:44PM EDT
Ailes Heats Up Cold Spring with Newspaper War
Apr 24 2009 12:33PM EDT
Happy Friday. Now Watch This.
Apr 24 2009 10:24AM EDT
Idle Chatter: NPR Cutbacks, Jon Meacham, more
Apr 24 2009 8:50AM EDT
Late Breaks: Twitter and the 'Times,' more
Apr 23 2009 5:59PM EDT
CNN Partner's Polling Finds CNN Fair, Balanced
Apr 23 2009 4:10PM EDT
'Scientific American' Editor Out in Reorg
Apr 23 2009 3:19PM EDT
Idle Chatter: MySpace, Nerve, 'Millionaire,' more
Apr 23 2009 8:20AM EDT
Late Breaks: 'Observer' Editor Resigns, more
Apr 22 2009 4:15PM EDT
One Marriage, One Memoir, Two Opinions
Apr 22 2009 2:31PM EDT

Links

Also in Portfolio.com

Visit our partner sites

Subscribe to a magazine:

Visit our sister sites:

Quotes delayed 15 minutes for NASDAQ. 20 minutes for NYSE and AMEX. Market Data provided by Interactive Data. Terms & Conditions. Powered and implemented by Interactive Data Managed Solutions. Company fundamental data provided by Hemscott. Economic data provided by Econoday. News provided by Comtex. Sec Filings data provided by Edgars. The Wall Street Horizon National Consumer Interest Rate Survey. ©2009 Wall Street Horizon. PMMS Mortgage Data ©2009 Freddie Mac. Mortgage averages are for conforming mortgages with 20% down.