For Phony Memoir's Editor, It's Strike Two
For a daily reporter, two years often seems more like twenty. So thanks to Gawker for reminding me of something I'd totally forgotten: that I exposed a certain editor's susceptibility to phony memoirs back in March 2006.
That editor is Riverhead's Sarah McGrath, who was responsible for Love & Consequences, a thoroughly fictional account by Margaret Seltzer of the youth she supposedly spent dodging bullets and cooking crack in South Central L.A.
In McGrath's previous job, at Simon & Schuster's Scribner imprint, she bought, for a reported $900,000, a book called How to Wear Black, a purported memoir of life in the fashion stratosphere by a British writer, Emily Davies. Only, as I discovered, Davies hadn't lived the experiences chronicled in her proposal -- she'd cribbed them from various published articles. Simon & Schuster ended up killing the book, and McGrath took a new job only a few weeks later. (My articles dissecting the fraud are in WWD's password-protected archives, but you can read about the deception here.)
Love & Consequences has brought to a fresh boil the always-simmering debate over whether book publishers have an obligation to fact-check memoirs. Publishers have various reasons to oppose it, from the supposedly prohibitive cost to Nan Talese's much-mocked claim that it would be "very insulting and divisive in the author-editor relationship."
If publishers aren't going to institute fact-checking procedures, then they had better, at a minimum, make sure their bullshit-detectors are in working order. Sarah McGrath's, it's clear, is broken.
- Late Breaks: 'WSJ' vs. 'NYT,' Layoff Roundup, more
- Nov 21 2008 4:48PM EST
- Duly Quoted: Was 'WSJ' a Big Fat Waste of Dough?
- Nov 21 2008 4:10PM EST
- How Dividend Cut Puts NYT's Future in Play
- Nov 21 2008 10:52AM EST
- Idle Chatter: Ted's Sales; Angelina's Leverage
- Nov 21 2008 8:37AM EST
- Late Breaks: Slimming Down AP, and Fat Kids
- Nov 20 2008 5:39PM EST
- New York Times Co. Slashes Dividend
- Nov 20 2008 4:17PM EST
- Oprah Headmistress to Drop Suit Against Huffpo
- Nov 20 2008 2:43PM EST
- News Corp. Re-ups Ailes as Fox News Chief
- Nov 20 2008 1:29PM EST
- Garfield: There's No Future Model for Online News
- Nov 20 2008 11:23AM EST
- Idle Chatter: Bad Day to Own Media Stock
- Nov 20 2008 8:35AM EST
- Late Breaks: Steve Jobs Blogger Gagged, more
- Nov 19 2008 5:36PM EST
- AMI Chief Asks Employees to Back Auto Bailout
- Nov 19 2008 2:49PM EST
- 'PC Magazine' Crossing the Digital-Only Frontier
- Nov 19 2008 12:25PM EST
- Number Crunch: Downsizing at the Business Mags
- Nov 19 2008 11:10AM EST
- Idle Chatter: 'Cottage' Carnage at Time Inc., more
- Nov 19 2008 8:20AM EST
Categories
Links
- Contact Me
- News After Newspapers
- Romenesko

- Gawker

- Ad Age

- WWD's Memo Pad

- Keith Kelly

- NYT Media

- Jon Fine

- TVNewser

- Magazine Death Pool

- HuffPo Media

- Radar

- Galleycat

- Book Standard

- News Hounds

- Newsbusters

- Jezebel

- CBS Public Eye

- Editor & Publisher

- Hollywood Wiretap

- The Media Pundit

- FAIR

- I Want Media

- Viral Video

- Nikki Finke

- MediaFile

- Silicon Alley Insider

- Paid Content

- Valleywag

- Channel '08 -- Campaign Ads

- Cover Awards

- Talking Biz News

- SI.com - Richard Deitsch

- Gapper Blog - Media

- Jon Friedman










