BizJournals Portfolio
Mar 07 2008 12:00am EDT

For Phony Memoir's Editor, It's Strike Two

For a daily reporter, two years often seems more like twenty. So thanks to Gawker for reminding me of something I'd totally forgotten: that I exposed a certain editor's susceptibility to phony memoirs back in March 2006.

That editor is Riverhead's Sarah McGrath, who was responsible for Love & Consequences, a thoroughly fictional account by Margaret Seltzer of the youth she supposedly spent dodging bullets and cooking crack in South Central L.A.

In McGrath's previous job, at Simon & Schuster's Scribner imprint, she bought, for a reported $900,000, a book called How to Wear Black, a purported memoir of life in the fashion stratosphere by a British writer, Emily Davies. Only, as I discovered, Davies hadn't lived the experiences chronicled in her proposal -- she'd cribbed them from various published articles. Simon & Schuster ended up killing the book, and McGrath took a new job only a few weeks later. (My articles dissecting the fraud are in WWD's password-protected archives, but you can read about the deception here.)

Love & Consequences has brought to a fresh boil the always-simmering debate over whether book publishers have an obligation to fact-check memoirs. Publishers have various reasons to oppose it, from the supposedly prohibitive cost to Nan Talese's much-mocked claim that it would be "very insulting and divisive in the author-editor relationship."

If publishers aren't going to institute fact-checking procedures, then they had better, at a minimum, make sure their bullshit-detectors are in working order. Sarah McGrath's, it's clear, is broken.


Comments

If you are commenting using a Facebook account, your profile information may be displayed with your comment depending on your privacy settings. By leaving the 'Post to Facebook' box selected, your comment will be published to your Facebook profile in addition to the space below.


Connect With Portfolio.com

Come on, like us—you know you want to.

Follow us and if you're an innovative entrepreneur, we'll return the favor.

Today's top stories, conversation starters, and the back nine business bites.

spotlight on

People & Ideas

Whisky To-Go-Go

Now there's a company that let's you taste your knowledge of fine blended Scotches by mixing a whisky of your own. Read More