Sign In
SHARE
The Critic Who Can't Stop Bashing 'Details'
What is Peter Carlson's beef with Details?
As the Washington Post's magazine critic, Carlson routinely excoriated the Conde Nast men's magazine, calling it "idiotic" (April 11, 2006), "always moronic" (Dec. 21, 2004), "pathetic" (June 29, 2004) and "truly awful" (ibid).
Though his "Magazine Reader" column has been discontinued, Carlson revisits his favorite issue today in the Arts & Living section, tearing into the holiday issue on stands now. "Details isn't entirely filled with moronic fashion tips," he reports. "There are also moronic articles."
Carlson seems to have a special place in his spleen for Conde Nast men's magazines, and for the word "moronic." (Portfolio is part of Conde Nast, by the way.) He called Men's Vogue a "horrific idea" whose "name is a truly moronic oxymoron," and called on readers to boycott Cargo, which he labeled possibly "the worst idea for a magazine in human history." (They did; Cargo is out of business now.)
I asked Details editor in chief Dan Peres if he has any idea why Carlson finds his magazine so profoundly repellent. In his reply, he suggested that the 55-year-old writer is not exactly the target reader: "Peter Carlson critiquing Details is like me critiquing AARP Monthly -- there's bound to be a disconnect."
CORRECTION, 6:39 p.m.: Though this archive ends in 2005, Carlson informs me that his column is still very much a going concern. It runs every other Tuesday.
Loading...
Thank you for registering as a Portfolio.com Insider. Your comment has been added.
Create Your Public Profile
- Conde Nast Closing 'Portfolio'
- Apr 27 2009 10:02AM EDT
- Newspaper Circ: 'WSJ' Gains as 'NY Post' Tumbles
- Apr 27 2009 9:32AM EDT
- Idle Chatter: The Prognosis for Newspapers, more
- Apr 27 2009 8:55AM EDT
- Late Breaks: MySpace, NYT, 'New York'
- Apr 24 2009 4:01PM EDT
- Nostalgia, Entitlement and Murdoch's 'Journal'
- Apr 24 2009 4:00PM EDT
- Huffpo's Lerer on the 'New and Better' Journalism
- Apr 24 2009 12:44PM EDT
- Ailes Heats Up Cold Spring with Newspaper War
- Apr 24 2009 12:33PM EDT
- Happy Friday. Now Watch This.
- Apr 24 2009 10:24AM EDT
- Idle Chatter: NPR Cutbacks, Jon Meacham, more
- Apr 24 2009 8:50AM EDT
- Late Breaks: Twitter and the 'Times,' more
- Apr 23 2009 5:59PM EDT
- CNN Partner's Polling Finds CNN Fair, Balanced
- Apr 23 2009 4:10PM EDT
- 'Scientific American' Editor Out in Reorg
- Apr 23 2009 3:19PM EDT
- Idle Chatter: MySpace, Nerve, 'Millionaire,' more
- Apr 23 2009 8:20AM EDT
- Late Breaks: 'Observer' Editor Resigns, more
- Apr 22 2009 4:15PM EDT
- One Marriage, One Memoir, Two Opinions
- Apr 22 2009 2:31PM EDT
Archive
Categories
Links
- Contact Me
- News After Newspapers
- Romenesko
- Gawker
- Ad Age
- WWD's Memo Pad
- Keith Kelly
- NYT Media
- Jon Fine
- TVNewser
- Magazine Death Pool
- HuffPo Media
- Galleycat
- News Hounds
- Newsbusters
- Jezebel
- Editor & Publisher
- Hollywood Wiretap
- The Media Pundit
- FAIR
- I Want Media
- Viral Video
- Nikki Finke
- MediaFile
- The Business Insider
- Paid Content
- Valleywag
- Cover Awards
- Talking Biz News
- SI.com - Richard Deitsch
- Gapper Blog - Media
- Jon Friedman
- Nieman Journalism Lab
- NY Observer media page
- Media Shift
- Tyndall Report
- Media Nation
