How the 'Post' Keeps Gays From the Newsroom
How do gay employees of the New York Post feel about working at an institution that portrays homosexuals as a bunch of whiny, effeminate sodomites? Is the newsroom as uncomfortable a place for them as the paper's frequent gay-baiting might suggest?
I figured the best way to answer these questions would be to ask some of the Post's prominent gay writers and editors. Unfortunately, I hit a snag: There aren't any.
In fact, while I know plenty of gay people who work at The New York Times, the Daily News and just about every other big media organization in town, I had to search high and low to find a single gay Post staffer.
The Post insiders I asked weren't much help. "I'm trying to think of any gay employees I worked with there, but I can't," said one former longtime editor. "I couldn't even tell you the last gay employee who worked there," said a writer.
So I changed tacks. I called up the National Lesbian and Gay Journalists Association to see if there have been any complaints about discriminatory hiring or treatment of workers at the Post. That was when I found my first gay Postie. His name is Eric Hegedus, and he's a page designer. He's also the NLGJA's national president.
He told me he couldn't comment. Quite the muscular group, that NLGJA.
After some more inquiries, I learned that the Post does, in fact, have a handful of gay staffers, some of whom have voiced objections to the paper's coverage to colleagues and higher-ups. (A Post spokesman was unaware of any complaints.) Still, gays are seriously underrepresented there, especially in the ranks of upper management and in the 10th floor newsroom, where the hard news is reported and edited, and where they're all but nonexistent.
The question is: Why?
The consensus among the Posties I spoke with is that the paper doesn't discriminate in its hiring. Rather, the paucity of gay employees results from the Post's stridently anti-P.C. editorial tone and frathouse office atmosphere. "It's not a culturally welcoming environment," says the ex-editor. "It's a locker-room environment -- raucous, sexist, quite misogynist."
Some of it flows from editor in chief Col Allan, whom the ex-editor describes as an equal-opportunity offender: "He makes everyone feel uncomfortable. Any weakness or perceived difference he dumps on. He's the kind of guy who can make racist and sexist jokes and get away with it."
"It's not a place for anybody who's particularly sensitive about anything," agrees former reporter Ian Spiegelman. "For most people, you have to turn off a part of your brain when you work there."
Spiegelman worked at Page Six, the paper's second most anti-gay section, after the editorial pages. Although the gossip column officially has a policy against outing closeted homosexuals, it delights in taunting them as "swishy" and, more recently, "toe-tappers. It's also home to cartoonist Sean Delonas, whose drawings of sheep are meant to suggest a link between homosexuality and bestiality.
Though I struggle to believe it, Spiegelman insists, "I know the people who write Page Six and there's not a homophobe among them." (It should be noted here that Spielgelman was fired in part for using the word "faggot" in a threatening email to a heterosexual antagonist.) As for the paper as a whole, he says, "I can't imagine anybody being turned down for a job there because they seemed to be gay, but it's also hard to imagine a gay person wanting to work there."
There's probably something to this. One gay man I interviewed recalled working at the Post in 2001 when a Manhattan school canceled its celebration of Mother's Day, citing the number of students with single or same-sex parents. The Post's headline: "SCHOOL KILLS MOTHER'S DAY: Gay parents force principal to ban cards."
"It was very difficult for me to walk through the front door of the paper that day," he says.
Every time the Post does something outrageous, I wonder: How are they able to get away with it? Why have they been able to avoid a Don Imus moment? There's no simple answer, but the staff's homogeneity is a key part of it. Recall that in the Imus case, it was a black MSNBC employee who blew the whistle on his "nappy-headed hos" remark to the National Association of Black Journalists, whose call for a boycott started the drumbeat for Imus's firing.
Newsroom diversity doesn't just happen. Newspapers and other media organizations strive to attain it, in part to make sure they don't accidentally trample over some group's sensitivities out of sheer ignorance. They know they need someone on hand to say, "Hey guys, I'm gay/black/Muslim/disabled/etc., and I don't think you realize how offensive this story we're about to print really is."
Of course, for Col Allan and his band of "pirates," offending right-thinking people is in the mission statement. But to the extent that their ability to keep on offending people without interference from within depends on preserving an environment where gays feel unwanted, they're guilty of something a whole lot more sinister than journalistic malpractice.
- Late Breaks: Sibling Rivalry at News Corp., more
- Dec 2 2008 4:49PM EST
- Two Murdoch Parties, But Wendi Gets Her Way
- Dec 2 2008 4:10PM EST
- Why NBC News Should've Known Better
- Dec 2 2008 10:42AM EST
- MSNBC: The Fox News of the Left?
- Dec 2 2008 9:11AM EST
- Idle Chatter: Glenn Beck, Harvey Weinstein, more
- Dec 2 2008 8:48AM EST
- Late Breaks: Meet the New 'Meet the Press' Host
- Dec 1 2008 6:14PM EST
- Rather: 'Fear Rules Every Newsroom in the Country'
- Dec 1 2008 12:38PM EST
- Gap's NBC Embrace Is Serendipity, Not Synergy
- Dec 1 2008 11:38AM EST
- The Takeaway: Murdoch Biography Arrives
- Dec 1 2008 10:20AM EST
- Idle Chatter: Anchors Away; Outsourcing MoDo
- Dec 1 2008 8:26AM EST
- Late Breaks: Go Stuff Some Turkey
- Nov 26 2008 5:31PM EST
- Jeff Jarvis Declares the Death of the Interview
- Nov 26 2008 12:51PM EST
- Idle Chatter: Ashlee Simpson, Bane of Copy Editors
- Nov 26 2008 8:56AM EST
- Late Breaks: Hannity's Little Helper
- Nov 25 2008 4:43PM EST
- Nice Time-ing: Ann the Ax-Wielder Honored
- Nov 25 2008 12:47PM EST
Categories
Links
- Contact Me
- News After Newspapers
- Romenesko

- Gawker

- Ad Age

- WWD's Memo Pad

- Keith Kelly

- NYT Media

- Jon Fine

- TVNewser

- Magazine Death Pool

- HuffPo Media

- Radar

- Galleycat

- Book Standard

- News Hounds

- Newsbusters

- Jezebel

- CBS Public Eye

- Editor & Publisher

- Hollywood Wiretap

- The Media Pundit

- FAIR

- I Want Media

- Viral Video

- Nikki Finke

- MediaFile

- Silicon Alley Insider

- Paid Content

- Valleywag

- Channel '08 -- Campaign Ads

- Cover Awards

- Talking Biz News

- SI.com - Richard Deitsch

- Gapper Blog - Media

- Jon Friedman










