BizJournals Portfolio
Home >   Business Views, Opinions and Blogs >   Business Blogs >   Market Movers >  

Footnote Of The Day

Market Movers

by Felix Salmon
Main
Are Banks Systematically Evicting Renters?   Chinese iPod Datapoint of the Day

Recent Blog Posts

Links

Aug 08 2008 5:43am EDT

Footnote of the Day

As cited by Z (a/k/a Olivier Fouquet), a commenter at Crooked Timber:

In fact, almost all non trivial results of [...] can be put in the following tripartite classification:
(a) Results for which a (sound) reference is given, but of which no proof can be found in the given reference (e.g. loc. cit., Prop. 4.2.2(i)).
(b) Results for which "a proof will appear elsewhere", and for which no proof has appeared anywhere (not even in a preprint, twenty months after the publication of [...]). (See e.g. Theorem 3.2.1 loc. cit.)
(c) Results for which a reference is given, that does not exist. Indeed, many results are said to be proved in [...]. This preprint does not exist, either in paper or electronic form, under this name or any other, and for obvious reasons will never do.

It's well known that mathematicians love elegant proofs; they clearly love elegant take-downs as well.

. □

Comments

If you are commenting using a Facebook account, your profile information may be displayed with your comment depending on your privacy settings. By leaving the 'Post to Facebook' box selected, your comment will be published to your Facebook profile in addition to the space below.


Connect With Portfolio.com
Like Portfolio on Facebook

Come on, like us—you know you want to.

Follow Portfolio on Twitter

Follow us and if you're an innovative entrepreneur, we'll return the favor.

The Mix

Today's top stories, conversation starters, and the back nine business bites.

spotlight on

People & Ideas

Whisky To-Go-Go

Now there's a company that let's you taste your knowledge of fine blended Scotches by mixing a whisky of your own. Read More