Why Hedge Funds Lose Money in Volatile Markets
Insight from Baruch:
The strategists at my beloved employer told the punters, correctly, that this year would see a lot of volatility in equities. So, they said, increase allocation to equity long short, which struck me as precisely the wrong thing to do. Paradoxically in times like this it is the dumb, directional money, the long only crowd, who can ride out volatility better.
This makes sense to me, and helps explain why volatility is bad for hedge funds. If you're doing any kind of relative-value play, then volatility works against you in that it increases the chances that you'll get stopped out before you make any profits. It's only the noise traders who really make money from volatility, and they're actually a minority in the hedge-fund world.
No hedge is perfect, and in periods of unusual volatility, hedges are more likely to fail. Hedge funds, it seems, are much more likely to outperform in a low-volatility bear market than in a high-volatility messy market like we have right now. But there isn't an asset class devoted to making money from volatility, so investors throw their money at hedge funds anyway, generally in the hope that if a fund hasn't blown up yet, it might somehow avoid blowing up in future.
Update: After four comments saying exactly the same thing, I clearly nead to clarify. Of course there are ways of making money from volatility: you just, well, go long volatility, normally in the options market. But that's a strategy, not an asset class. For an investor trying to work out where to put his money, the zero-sum game that is the options market is not really investable, let alone a good idea.
- Extra Credit, Tuesday Edition
- Jul 8 2008 6:59PM EDT
- Don't Go To Brazil, Young Man
- Jul 8 2008 6:54PM EDT
- What is a Covered Bond?
- Jul 8 2008 5:08PM EDT
- A Look at Long-Term Stock Valuations
- Jul 8 2008 1:36PM EDT
- Market Rumors: Inevitable
- Jul 8 2008 10:31AM EDT
- Bad Ideas at the WSJ, Customization Edition
- Jul 8 2008 9:39AM EDT
- American Obesity
- Jul 8 2008 7:50AM EDT
- The Economic Policy of John McCain
- Jul 8 2008 7:04AM EDT
- Why GM Should Embrace Bankruptcy
- Jul 8 2008 5:28AM EDT
- Transparency: Sometimes Even Investment Banks Like It
- Jul 7 2008 6:25PM EDT
- Extra Credit, Monday Edition
- Jul 7 2008 3:23PM EDT
- The Worst Beneficiaries of a Billion-Dollar Will
- Jul 7 2008 1:36PM EDT
- Carl Icahn's Communication Problem: Solved!
- Jul 7 2008 12:12PM EDT
- Manhattan Housing Datapoint of the Day
- Jul 7 2008 11:46AM EDT
- How Risk is Like Religion
- Jul 7 2008 10:51AM EDT
Archive
Jul 2008
Categories
- Davos 2008
- IMF
- M&A
- accounting
- announcements
- architecture
- art
- banking
- bankruptcy
- ben stein watch
- blogonomics
- bonds and loans
- charts
- china
- cities
- climate change
- commercial property
- commodities
- consumption
- credit ratings
- crime
- defenestrations
- derivatives
- design
- development
- economics
- education
- emerging markets
- entitlements
- euro
- facial hair
- fashion
- fiscal and monetary policy
- food
- foreign exchange
- fraud
- gambling
- geopolitics
- governance
- healthcare
- hedge funds
- holidays
- housing
- humor
- immigration
- infrastructure
- insurance
- intellectual property
- investing
- labor
- language
- law
- leadership
- leaks
- media
- milken 2008
- pay
- personal finance
- philanthropy
- politics
- prediction markets
- private equity
- privatization
- productivity
- publishing
- rants
- regulation
- remainders
- satire
- science
- shareholder activism
- sports
- statistics
- stocks
- taxes
- technocrats
- technology
- trade
- travel
- water
- wealth
- world bank
Links
- Email Felix Salmon
- Alphaville

- Marginal Revolution

- The Panelist

- FP Passport

- Overcoming Bias

- Andrew Leonard

- Barry Ritholtz

- Brad Setser

- Carbon Tax Center

- Calculated Risk

- Greg Mankiw

- Free Exchange

- Dean Baker

- Alexander Campbell

- Kash Mansori

- The Bayesian Heresy

- A Fistful of Euros

- John Quiggin

- Michael Mandel

- Lance Knobel

- Mark Thoma

- Dan Gross

- Curbed

- Streetsblog

- Chris Anderson

- Deal Journal

- MarketBeat

- DealBook

- DealBreaker

- Carl Bialik

- Michelle Leder

- Brad DeLong

- The Epicurean Dealmaker

- Naked Capitalism

- Ultimi Barbarorum

- Econospeak

- Fortune: Daily Briefing

- Financial Crookery





