BizJournals Portfolio
Feb 29 2008 12:00am EDT

Apple Buybacks: Still a Bad Idea

Back in December, I wasn't a fan of Apple buying back its stock. I'm still not a fan, despite the fact that Apple stock has dropped 40% since then and the fact that Arik Hesseldahl says that a buyback is a very good idea: "word of a buyback would probably give the stock price the kind of upward lift it needs," he says.

Um, needs? Why does Apple need a higher stock price? So that it can use its valuable stock as an acquisition currency? No, it can't be that, since a large part of Hesseldahl's argument is that Apple doesn't really have any major acquisitions on the horizon. Is it for the sake of Apple's most loyal shareholders? No: they're generally happy with Apple's long-term price appreciation. The main beneficiaries of a buyback would be the momentum traders who are exactly the kind of shareholders no company wants.

And I'm particularly unimpressed by this part of Hesseldahl's piece:

I found 295 companies on the S&P 500-stock index that have announced stock buybacks since the start of 2003, and they averaged a gain of more than 66% over five years. Gainers outnumbered losers by nearly 5 to 1, with the gainers improving their stock prices by an average of more than 150%.

Wow, the 295 companies averaged a gain of 66% over five years? That's exactly the gain that the S&P as a whole has had over the past five years! You'd almost think that buybacks made no difference at all!

As for the 150% figure, it seems extremely weird to me. Let's say that you started with six companies, all of which were trading at $100. Five of them increased by 150% to $250 apiece, and the sixth went bankrupt with all stockholders wiped out. You started with $600, and you ended with $1,250 - for a minimum gain of 108% over five years. Now square that with the 66% figure.

Now, all that said, I don't necessarily think that Apple should simply continue to accumulate cash for no particular reason except for the fact that it has historically paid no dividend. A modest dividend, tied to profits, makes perfect sense. A buyback, on the other hand, doesn't.


Comments

If you are commenting using a Facebook account, your profile information may be displayed with your comment depending on your privacy settings. By leaving the 'Post to Facebook' box selected, your comment will be published to your Facebook profile in addition to the space below.


Connect With Portfolio.com

Come on, like us—you know you want to.

Follow us and if you're an innovative entrepreneur, we'll return the favor.

Today's top stories, conversation starters, and the back nine business bites.

spotlight on

People & Ideas

Whisky To-Go-Go

Now there's a company that let's you taste your knowledge of fine blended Scotches by mixing a whisky of your own. Read More