Sign In
SHARE
E*Trade: In Defense of Prashant Bhatia
Just as one shouldn't shout "fire" in a crowded theater, one shouldn't shout "run on the bank" in an analyst's report. If you do that, as Citigroup's Prashant Bhatia notoriously did in his report on E*Trade, you risk your report turning into a self-fulfilling prophecy. After all, no bank is immune to a bank run.
At the same time, however, I think it's rash to simply blame Bhatia and call him "irresponsible" for publishing what was actually a pretty sober piece of analysis. The key datapoint: half of E*Trade’s deposits, or $15 billion, are in accounts that contain more than $100,000, and are therefore not insured by the FDIC. If I was an E*Trade depositor, and I had more than $100,000 in the bank, and I saw that E*Trade was announcing subprime write-downs of unknown size, then I wouldn't need Prashant Bhatia to tell me to move my money somewhere a little bit safer.
If I were E*Trade, then, I wouldn't be running around shooting the messenger, I would be running around spending as much money as it took to buy private insurance on all of my deposits over and above the FDIC cap. Either that, or I would be simply trying to sell myself to someone rather better-capitalized.
As for Bhatia, he called it right. There are a million different things which can cause a bank run, and analysts' reports are hardly top of the list. What's more, for the time being there's still no evidence of any bank run at all. Although that might change tomorrow, when depositors start seeing the headlines. Even then, however, the proximate cause of the bank run would be the drop in the share price, not Bhatia's report per se. As we've seen with shares from Crocs to Sotheby's, there's no shortage of stocks which turn out to be just waiting for an excuse to crater. E*Trade turned out to be one of them, and that's not Bhatia's fault.
Loading...
Thank you for registering as a Portfolio.com Insider. Your comment has been added.
Create Your Public Profile
- The Times' Rorshach Geithner Story
- Apr 27 2009 9:26AM EDT
- Sinking Animal Spirits
- Apr 27 2009 8:45AM EDT
- Counter-cyclical Urban Policy
- Apr 26 2009 10:00AM EDT
- Be Your Own Counterfeiter
- Apr 26 2009 9:36AM EDT
- Being Tim Geithner
- Apr 25 2009 12:37PM EDT
- Notes From a Press Conference Naif
- Apr 25 2009 9:41AM EDT
- What Good is the News?
- Apr 25 2009 8:32AM EDT
- Stressful Enough
- Apr 24 2009 2:29PM EDT
- Not Regretting the Pound
- Apr 24 2009 1:09PM EDT
- Introducing the New Ford Squeeze
- Apr 24 2009 9:47AM EDT
- Non-Economic Questions of the Day
- Apr 24 2009 9:12AM EDT
- The Stress Test Blind Alley
- Apr 24 2009 8:36AM EDT
- Happy Hour
- Apr 23 2009 9:40PM EDT
- Recovery Without Rebalancing
- Apr 23 2009 6:13PM EDT
- The Shape of Your Recession
- Apr 23 2009 5:11PM EDT
Archive
Categories
Links
- Email Ryan Avent
- Econospeak
- Financial Crookery
- The Epicurean Dealmaker
- Naked Capitalism
- Alphaville
- Marginal Revolution
- The Panelist
- FP Passport
- Overcoming Bias
- Andrew Leonard
- Barry Ritholtz
- Brad Setser
- Carbon Tax Center
- Calculated Risk
- Greg Mankiw
- Free Exchange
- Dean Baker
- Alexander Campbell
- Kash Mansori
- The Bayesian Heresy
- A Fistful of Euros
- John Quiggin
- Michael Mandel
- Lance Knobel
- Mark Thoma
- Dan Gross
- Curbed
- Streetsblog
- Chris Anderson
- Deal Journal
- MarketBeat
- DealBook
- DealBreaker
- Carl Bialik
- Michelle Leder
- Brad DeLong
- Ultimi Barbarorum
