Beware Copyright Statistics
Dean Baker is unimpressed by studies showing vast losses to the US economy from piracy of intellectual property. He picks on a Washington Post article by Frank Ahrens, which quotes a study concluding that "intellectual property piracy -- theft of music, movies, video games and software -- costs the U.S. economy $58 billion per year and 350,000 lost jobs in the entertainment industry and its supplying industries."
Baker doesn't like the economics:
The article wrongly claims that these violations cost the economy money. This is untrue on its face. The losses to the industry are gains to consumers, and those who know economics would know immediately that the gains to consumers vastly exceed the losses to the industry. Some economic analysis would be useful in this article.
Baker's right that the study, from the IPI, makes no attempt to calculate the gains to consumers from IP piracy. But in fact the study is worse than that, because it also makes no attempt to calculate the gains to the entertainment industry from IP piracy.
The methodology of the study is simple. The researchers (the author of the study is Stephen Siwek) take their best guess of how many CDs and DVDs are illegally copied or downloaded each year. In the case of CDs, they reckon that 1.4 billion copied CDs are sold, along with 20 billion illegal MP3 downloads. They then assume that 65.7% of purchasers of counterfeit CDs would have bought the real thing instead, had the counterfeit not been available, and that 10% of people downloading songs illegally would have paid for their music at a legitimate download site such as iTunes instead.
From these numbers they come to the conclusion the entertainment industry loses $1.6 billion to fake CDs, and another $3.7 billion to illegal downloading. They then add those numbers together, to get a total of $5.3 billion, and apply a "multiplier" which allows them to reach the conclusion that the total loss to the US economy is $12.5 billion per year.
At no point in the study is the idea considered that wider dissemination of music might actually help the music industry at all: I'm almost surprised that Siwek doesn't calculate the number of people who might buy CDs but don't because they can hear music free on the radio instead. Music is naturally viral: the more people who listen to any given artist, the more people who are likely to go out and buy that artist's music. And then, of course, there's all the extra revenue to the music industry from merchandise and concert tickets which are sold to people who didn't buy the CD but still became fans.
Now I'm not saying that any of these effects completely couteract the losses due to piracy, because I have no idea whether they do or not. But these effects do exist, and it might be intellectually honest to at least take a stab at estimating their magnitude before coming to the conclusion that the US entertainment industry "loses" tens of billions of dollars a year to piracy.
In fact, of course, one can simply look at the stock price of entertainment-industry companies to see that the advent of piracy doesn't seem to have done them a vast amount of visible harm. That's why they need to wheel out researchers such as Siwek to try and demonstrate assertions which, as Baker quite rightly says, are untrue on their face.
Loading...
Thank you for registering as a Portfolio.com Insider. Your comment has been added.
Create Your Public Profile- The Times' Rorshach Geithner Story
- Apr 27 2009 9:26AM EDT
- Sinking Animal Spirits
- Apr 27 2009 8:45AM EDT
- Counter-cyclical Urban Policy
- Apr 26 2009 10:00AM EDT
- Be Your Own Counterfeiter
- Apr 26 2009 9:36AM EDT
- Being Tim Geithner
- Apr 25 2009 12:37PM EDT
- Notes From a Press Conference Naif
- Apr 25 2009 9:41AM EDT
- What Good is the News?
- Apr 25 2009 8:32AM EDT
- Stressful Enough
- Apr 24 2009 2:29PM EDT
- Not Regretting the Pound
- Apr 24 2009 1:09PM EDT
- Introducing the New Ford Squeeze
- Apr 24 2009 9:47AM EDT
- Non-Economic Questions of the Day
- Apr 24 2009 9:12AM EDT
- The Stress Test Blind Alley
- Apr 24 2009 8:36AM EDT
- Happy Hour
- Apr 23 2009 9:40PM EDT
- Recovery Without Rebalancing
- Apr 23 2009 6:13PM EDT
- The Shape of Your Recession
- Apr 23 2009 5:11PM EDT
Categories
Links
- Email Ryan Avent
- Econospeak

- Financial Crookery

- The Epicurean Dealmaker

- Naked Capitalism

- Alphaville

- Marginal Revolution

- The Panelist

- FP Passport

- Overcoming Bias

- Andrew Leonard

- Barry Ritholtz

- Brad Setser

- Carbon Tax Center

- Calculated Risk

- Greg Mankiw

- Free Exchange

- Dean Baker

- Alexander Campbell

- Kash Mansori

- The Bayesian Heresy

- A Fistful of Euros

- John Quiggin

- Michael Mandel

- Lance Knobel

- Mark Thoma

- Dan Gross

- Curbed

- Streetsblog

- Chris Anderson

- Deal Journal

- MarketBeat

- DealBook

- DealBreaker

- Carl Bialik

- Michelle Leder

- Brad DeLong

- Ultimi Barbarorum







