BizJournals Portfolio
Home >   Business Views, Opinions and Blogs >   Business Blogs >   Market Movers >  

The Limits Of Empiricism

Market Movers

by Yves Smith and Felix Salmon
Main
Northern Rock: No Need to Panic   There's No Such Thing as an Objective Credit Rating

Recent Blog Posts

Links

Sep 17 2007 12:00am EDT

The Limits of Empiricism

Two interesting reviews today: David Leonhardt on Ian Ayres, and Daniel Davies on Steven Levitt and Roland Fryer. There's a meme catching hold – think Freakonomics and Moneyball – which says that rigorous empirical analysis can reveal otherwise-unobtainable insights. But these reviews, along with Davies's latest Freakonomics review (part four of a long, wonderful, and hilariously delayed series) constitute a rather interesting countermeme.

The problem is that attempts at rigorous empirical analysis have long since eclipsed the number of empirically-rigorous datasets available. And so you end up with Levitt and Fryer running regression analyses on a KKK dataset which is dominated by Pennsylvania and Ohio, or with Ayres gushing about call-center call times on the basis of some gushing coverage in a back-issue of Fast Company.

As Davies points out in his Freakonomics review, insofar as economics works it's largely because a lot of very smart people spent a great deal of time working out how to generate reliable statistics; and also because whenever someone does any kind of economics research, you can be sure that they're using the same statistics as everybody else. Similarly, insofar as Moneyball worked, that was probably due to the fact that baseball is one of the few other places where you can find a set of universally-accepted and exhaustive statistics. But when you start looking at phone-call durations or KKK membership, you've moved a very long way into much squishier territory.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Real Business, Real Results
Out of the 'Family'

Did anyone at Microsoft ever watch the (gasp!) offensively funny show Family Guy?

Cruz Missile Lands

Ex-Morgan Stanley exec Zoe Cruz is now heading her own hedge fund. Are Wall Street's leaders done?

Scandal Chic

Martha, Bernie and Skilling know that what you wear for court can go a long way in public perception.

spotlight on

Health Care

Bad to the Bone No More

Companies such as General Mills say they're stepping up efforts to change employees' bad behavior and promote healthier lifestyles. Read More