Dispelling the Myth of Low Unemployment
Yves Smith of Naked Capitalism submits:
Doing some weekend catch-up, and a reader pointed me to a very good post by Barry Ritholtz, which confirms something I've believed but haven't gone to the trouble to prove, namely, that unemployment is much higher than the government releases would have one believe.
Full disclosure: I'm skeptical of quite a few government stats: GDP (badly tainted by hedonic adjustments), inflation (calculation methods revised in the 1990s which reduced annual reported CPI roughly 0.5%, which lowers Social Security and other CPI benefit adjustments; Ritholtz has been active on this beat), and more recently, job creation figures.
As Ritholtz says,
Anyone with more than 4 functioning brain cells should be able to figure out that a 4.5% unemployment rate would be causing huge labor shortages and wage increases.
On a macro level, if unemployment were as low as 4.5%, labor would have more bargaining power, which is inconsistent with widely reported stagnant wages.
On a micro level (yes, this is anecdotal), there are way way too many people over 40 who are un- or underemployed, or "retired" at a modest level when they'd rather be working. If you lose that corporate meal ticket, it is an long way down. In most cases, mid to senior corporate employees and professionals have narrow skills that can only be deployed in roles similar to the one they lost. And companies are onservative in how they hire (another sign of a slack labor market, since if it were hard to find workers, they'd have to accept employees who were a less than exact fit).
One of many tidbits from the other end of the employment spectrum: over 5000 people applied for 300 jobs at Apple's new Fifth Avenue store in Manhattan. Now perhaps many of them were employed in retail elsewhere and wanted what they thought was a kinder and cooler environment, but no matter how you dress it up, this is a on-your-feet-all-day, low-end job. Note that other large store openings in the New York metro area get similar overwhelming responses even though the BLS says the unemployment rate here is on par with the national level.
Back to Ritholtz:
So long as we are popping economic myths, let's also dispatch with the 4.5% unemployment rate. That number has been largely caused by several million exhaustees and others simply leaving the work force:The actual unemployment rate is closer to 6.5%.....This explains why wages and labor costs have remained subdued despite the alleged 4.5% UE measure.
- Extra Credit, Friday Edition
- Oct 10 2008 11:34PM EDT
- Paulson's Failure
- Oct 10 2008 11:03PM EDT
- Quitting the Hedge Fund Game
- Oct 10 2008 5:34PM EDT
- The Coalition of the Ailing
- Oct 10 2008 4:14PM EDT
- Recapitalization and the Implicit Treasury Guarantee
- Oct 10 2008 1:23PM EDT
- Lehman CDS: Low Price, Low Volume
- Oct 10 2008 12:24PM EDT
- Credit Markets Get Even Scarier
- Oct 10 2008 12:12PM EDT
- Information Overload Datapoint of the Day
- Oct 10 2008 10:23AM EDT
- Lehman CDS: It Won't Be Over Today
- Oct 10 2008 9:45AM EDT
- The Guarantee Plan
- Oct 10 2008 9:24AM EDT
- Extra Credit, Thursday Edition
- Oct 9 2008 11:51PM EDT
- The Unwinding of the Moral Hazard Trade
- Oct 9 2008 10:43PM EDT
- What Just Happened?
- Oct 9 2008 5:22PM EDT
- When Shipping Costs Plunge
- Oct 9 2008 1:39PM EDT
- Should the Fed Target Libor?
- Oct 9 2008 12:12PM EDT
Categories
Links
- Email Felix Salmon
- Alphaville

- Marginal Revolution

- The Panelist

- FP Passport

- Overcoming Bias

- Andrew Leonard

- Barry Ritholtz

- Brad Setser

- Carbon Tax Center

- Calculated Risk

- Greg Mankiw

- Free Exchange

- Dean Baker

- Alexander Campbell

- Kash Mansori

- The Bayesian Heresy

- A Fistful of Euros

- John Quiggin

- Michael Mandel

- Lance Knobel

- Mark Thoma

- Dan Gross

- Curbed

- Streetsblog

- Chris Anderson

- Deal Journal

- MarketBeat

- DealBook

- DealBreaker

- Carl Bialik

- Michelle Leder

- Brad DeLong

- The Epicurean Dealmaker

- Naked Capitalism

- Ultimi Barbarorum

- Econospeak

- Fortune: Daily Briefing

- Financial Crookery













