To Get Good Research, Phone the Analyst, Don't Read his Reports
Yet another reason to treat published sell-side analysis with a monster pinch of salt:
By offering analysts favours, ranging from recommending them for a job to agreeing to speak to their clients, executives sharply reduced the chances of a downgrade in the aftermath of poor results or a controversial deal...
Nearly four out of six Wall Street analysts admitted receiving favours from company executives.
The frequency of favours increased in line with the shortfall between the company's earnings and market expectations - a crucial determinant of analysts' stock ratings.
The favours were instrumental in securing better treatment from analysts. Analysts who received two favours were 50 per cent less likely than colleagues to downgrade the company after poor results, the academics say.
The most popular favour, mentioned by nearly a third of respondents, was putting ananalyst in touch with an executive at a rival firm, followed by the offer of career advice, and agreeing to meet with the analysts' clients.
The academics in question are Michael Clement from the University of Texas and James Westphal of University of Michigan. This is a great idea for a research paper, and it looks like a very strong result. (Although I haven't read the paper yet.)
The more that news like this comes out, the more it makes sense that sell-side firms are asking their analysts to cut back on published research, and spend more time talking one-on-one with their most valuable clients. I suspect the main reason sell-side analysts repay favors done for them by executives is that they know those executives will read their research. The executives will not, on the other, hand, find out what the analyst said on a private phone call with a hedge fund manager. So in those cases, the analyst can be rather more candid.
- Extra Credit, Tuesday Edition
- Dec 2 2008 11:57PM EST
- Q
- Dec 2 2008 10:34PM EST
- Finance Salaries: A Reply
- Dec 2 2008 8:07PM EST
- The Failed Subprime Clampdown
- Dec 2 2008 4:29PM EST
- Blame Citigroup's woes on the Citi-Travelers Merger
- Dec 2 2008 2:30PM EST
- Greenberg's Chutzpah
- Dec 2 2008 12:26PM EST
- Super-Seniors: The Last Word
- Dec 2 2008 12:04PM EST
- Pay Bankers Much Less
- Dec 2 2008 10:58AM EST
- Great Moments in Politics, California Edition
- Dec 2 2008 10:35AM EST
- Super-Seniors: Your Questions Answered
- Dec 2 2008 9:52AM EST
- What's a Super-Senior Tranche?
- Dec 1 2008 9:25PM EST
- Extra Credit, Monday Edition
- Dec 1 2008 6:29PM EST
- Zimbabwe: When Even the Central Bank Can't Keep Up
- Dec 1 2008 5:07PM EST
- Genius
- Dec 1 2008 4:14PM EST
- Adventures in Shopping, Black Friday Edition
- Dec 1 2008 3:55PM EST
Categories
Links
- Email Felix Salmon
- Alphaville

- Marginal Revolution

- The Panelist

- FP Passport

- Overcoming Bias

- Andrew Leonard

- Barry Ritholtz

- Brad Setser

- Carbon Tax Center

- Calculated Risk

- Greg Mankiw

- Free Exchange

- Dean Baker

- Alexander Campbell

- Kash Mansori

- The Bayesian Heresy

- A Fistful of Euros

- John Quiggin

- Michael Mandel

- Lance Knobel

- Mark Thoma

- Dan Gross

- Curbed

- Streetsblog

- Chris Anderson

- Deal Journal

- MarketBeat

- DealBook

- DealBreaker

- Carl Bialik

- Michelle Leder

- Brad DeLong

- The Epicurean Dealmaker

- Naked Capitalism

- Ultimi Barbarorum

- Econospeak

- Fortune: Daily Briefing

- Financial Crookery










