In Defense of Securitization
Tim Reason says that Jonathan Weil is right and I'm wrong when it comes to securitization:
Securitization may have its economic benefits, but it is also a ridiculous concept, a strained legal and accounting fiction invented by too-clever-by-half investment bankers. It proves John Kenneth Galbraith's contention that all financial innovations are just various forms of leverage with a new name.
Reason is no rube, and he knows the arguments why securitization is a good thing – I daresay he knows them better than I do. But his arguments against securitization seem weak. He's particularly worried about what happened at Aspen Technology, where a bunch of off-balance-sheet debt became on-balance-sheet debt when some accounting rules got violated.
But if you take a step back, it's really no big deal. If you're a company, you can raise money in two ways: you can sell debt, or you can sell equity. At any time, with the help of your friendly neighborhood financier, you can convert equity into debt, increasing your leverage, or you can convert debt into equity, decreasing it. Securitization is just one way of converting equity into debt – you lose cashflows which used to go straight to the top line, and you gain a large up-front cash payment.
When Aspen moved a bunch of cashflows which it thought were off its balance sheet back on to its balance sheet, the opposite thing happened. Its debt went up, yes. But its income went up too.
Let's say I own a money machine, which pours money down onto my head. The problem is that I don't have a suitable hat, which can catch the money so that I can then deposit it in a bank account. I go to my bank and ask for a loan to buy the hat, and they demand a very high rate of interest, because I'm a bad credit. (After all, I don't have any money – yet.) So raising debt to buy a hat is expensive. But raising equity to buy a hat is even more expensive: my friend Fred will pay for the hat, but only in return for a percentage of all the money that flows into it in perpetuity. I don't want to pay off Fred for ever, I just want to get that hat.
The answer to my problems is securitization. I go to my friend Tom, and he buys the hat. He doesn't give me the hat immediately – he keeps possession of it. And whenever money pours in, he takes that money until he's paid off the price of the hat, plus interest. But his interest rate is much lower than the bank's interest rate, because he has a guaranteed income from the hat – which is a much better credit than my sorry self. And when he's been paid back for the hat, I get the hat: it's all mine, and neither Tom nor Fred owns any of it.
That's why securitization is a good thing: it's a way of lowering borrowing costs for companies with bad credit. Which has got to be a good thing.
- The Weakness of the Treasury's New Bailout Plan
- Oct 13 2008 7:39PM EDT
- Are More Big Falls Ahead?
- Oct 13 2008 3:17PM EDT
- Credit Crunch Picture of the Day
- Oct 13 2008 1:38PM EDT
- Looking for Credit Data Online
- Oct 13 2008 12:08PM EDT
- CNBC's Gasparino Problem
- Oct 13 2008 11:16AM EDT
- Morgan Stanley: Not Out of the Woods
- Oct 13 2008 9:50AM EDT
- Krugman, Nobelist
- Oct 13 2008 9:28AM EDT
- The First Glimmers of Optimism
- Oct 13 2008 9:20AM EDT
- Extra Credit, Sunday Edition
- Oct 13 2008 12:26AM EDT
- Lehman CDS Datapoint of the Day
- Oct 12 2008 8:57PM EDT
- Anecdotal Crisis Datapoint of the Day
- Oct 12 2008 8:31PM EDT
- Europe to the Rescue?
- Oct 12 2008 7:53PM EDT
- The End of the BRIC Trade
- Oct 12 2008 4:06PM EDT
- The Amazing Ballooning RBS Bailout
- Oct 12 2008 2:46PM EDT
- Ben Stein Watch: October 12, 2008
- Oct 12 2008 2:12PM EDT
Categories
Links
- Email Felix Salmon
- Alphaville

- Marginal Revolution

- The Panelist

- FP Passport

- Overcoming Bias

- Andrew Leonard

- Barry Ritholtz

- Brad Setser

- Carbon Tax Center

- Calculated Risk

- Greg Mankiw

- Free Exchange

- Dean Baker

- Alexander Campbell

- Kash Mansori

- The Bayesian Heresy

- A Fistful of Euros

- John Quiggin

- Michael Mandel

- Lance Knobel

- Mark Thoma

- Dan Gross

- Curbed

- Streetsblog

- Chris Anderson

- Deal Journal

- MarketBeat

- DealBook

- DealBreaker

- Carl Bialik

- Michelle Leder

- Brad DeLong

- The Epicurean Dealmaker

- Naked Capitalism

- Ultimi Barbarorum

- Econospeak

- Fortune: Daily Briefing

- Financial Crookery












