The Logic Behind Law Firms' Bonus Matching
Are law firms "absolutely irrational, economically speaking" in awarding matching bonuses to associates each fall, as Andrew Ross Sorkin asserted in his Dealbook column in Sunday's New York Times? Not really.
Cravath, Swaine & Moore started the annual tradition by announcing special bonuses to associates of $10,000 to $50,000 in addition to regular bonuses of $35,000 to $50,000, based on seniority. Debevoise & Plimpton matched within days, and . . . well, you get the picture.
It is reflexive and expensive, but not necessarily illogical. Law firms can't get past the simple math in what has been dubbed "the war for talent," says Ward Bower of the law firm consulting firm Altman Weil.
Of the 40,000 law students who graduate each year, only 2,000 to 4,000 of them come from top schools. Otherwise, they're pretty much indistinguishable from each other—at first. Eventually, of course, the best associates become clear and are invited to become partners, but it takes a while for top performers to distinguish themselves.
So the starting salaries and the bonuses are "matchy-matchy" to encourage associates to stay on the plantation rather than risk having a recruiter at another firm poach the best prospects—at least until management sorts out who will be made partner and who will be invited to leave.
"They want to make the choice and not have the associate make the choice," says Bower.
by Karen Donovan
- End Comes Early for a Law Firm
- Oct 10 2008 5:25PM EDT
- The Smartest Guy in the Art Gallery?
- Oct 10 2008 4:05PM EDT
- Lehman's Leavings
- Oct 10 2008 2:33PM EDT
- Kill the Ratings Agencies
- Oct 10 2008 12:41PM EDT
- Look Who's Hopeful
- Oct 10 2008 11:52AM EDT
- Prescription for Accounting Cases
- Oct 9 2008 6:24PM EDT
- Tom Perkins' Yacht, Now Slightly Used
- Oct 9 2008 4:30PM EDT
- G.M., the 1929 Model
- Oct 9 2008 3:51PM EDT
- New Home for a Fallen Housing Giant
- Oct 9 2008 2:25PM EDT
- Man Bites Dog, Paper Sues Readers
- Oct 9 2008 1:15PM EDT
- Shorts Come In From the Cold
- Oct 9 2008 12:44PM EDT
- Over the Edge
- Oct 9 2008 11:45AM EDT
- Study Says Closing Roads Might Cut Congestion. Huh?
- Oct 9 2008 11:27AM EDT
- U.S. Debt Too Big for National Debt Clock
- Oct 9 2008 11:13AM EDT
- Celebs on Economy: They're Just Like Us!
- Oct 9 2008 7:48AM EDT











