BizJournals Portfolio

The PR Hall of Shame

The Toyota "unintended acceleration" saga is up there with the worst corporate PR disasters—mishandled information that put the public needlessly at risk.

Toyota Chief Grilled Toyota Chief Grilled

House committee tells Toyota's president and CEO Akio Toyoda to be prepared to pay for the deaths linked to his company's faulty cars. Read More

Managing a Crisis:
The Lessons of Toyota Managing a Crisis:<br>The Lessons of Toyota

Managers everywhere should pay attention to how Akio Toyoda defends himself and his company, Toyota Motors. With a few commonsense tips, a problem doesn’t have to be a full-blown crisis. Read More

The Pariah, a.k.a. Wall Street The Pariah, a.k.a. Wall Street

Tiger Woods and Akio Toyoda have high-profile problems. But neither man would change places with Goldman Sachs' Lloyd Blankfein, the posterboy for out-of-touch bankers. Here’s how Wall Street can turn its PR around. Read More
Toyota

At this point, the story about Toyota Motor Corp.'s problems with the "unintended acceleration" story should be shifting from news to history. It's two months old, and the company has recalled 8.2 million vehicles—at a cost about $2 billion.

It should be under control. But it's not. On Monday came news that a 61-year-old driver in California needed the help of state police to calm down his Toyota Prius, which he said accelerated on its own and reached a speed of 90 miles per hour.

The latest problems show that Toyota has failed to quickly get every single at-risk vehicle off the road and into the shop. That's a daunting task, for sure, but with a forthright PR strategy and a sure hand in charge of the logistics, it could have been done. It has delayed and denied instead.

Toyota now joins rank with other big companies that have impaired the public interest by ignoring or mishandling information. Here's a look at the PR Walk of Shame:

Toyota, 2010: The most disturbing aspect of the Toyota story is that the company appears to have dismissed early questions about the unintended acceleration problem. "Toyota either ignored or minimized reports of sudden acceleration," Representative Edolphus Towns, a Democrat from New York, told company chief Akio Toyoda, the grandson of the company founder, during a congressional hearing in February. So far, five deaths have been linked to the accelerator problem, and 29 more fatalities are under investigation. Toyota faces a criminal inquiry as well as untold civil penalties and lasting damage to its reputation and to its business.

Bridgestone/Firestone Inc., 2000: On August 9, 2000, the U.S. government announced that Bridgestone/Firestone would "voluntary" recall 6.5 million radial tires, at a cost of about $350 million. But the recall came two years after the first complaints that tires were coming apart at the seams and after a study by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration pointed a finger at the company. Almost 200 deaths were linked to the recalled tires.

Merck, 2004: The pharmaceuticals giant faced questions as early as 2000 about the safety of Vioxx. The painkiller, once prescribed to 80 million people worldwide, had been associated with heart-related health risks and the risk of stroke. It was recalled in 2004, and Merck set aside $970 million to cover legal costs. According to some estimates, the drug may have contributed to nearly 28,000 deaths.

Wyeth, 1997: Faced with a crisis over a potentially lethal antiobesity drug combo known as Fen-Phen, American Home Products decided to address the problem by changing its name to Wyeth. In retrospect, the name change has an air of black comedy about it. AHP marketed fenfluromine and phentermine, which were taken together as an obesity treatment. Fenfluromine was linked to lung and heart problems and government and private researchers examined 100 deaths among users. The liabilities in the case hit about $13 billion. Wyeth was eventually sold to Pfizer.

General Motors, 1963: In his groundbreaking book on the U.S. auto industry, Unsafe at Any Speed, consumer advocate Ralph Nader used one of his eight chapters to address concerns with the Chevrolet Corvair, a sporty compact car. The chapter famously asserts that the 1960-63 models were accident prone, and that GM ignored the advice of a Chevy mechanic, George Caramagna, who advised that an anti-roll bar be incorporated into the design. The company decided to address the situation by developing special tire pressures, which weren't well communicated to salespeople and owners. And GM hired detectives to dig up dirt on Nader.


Steve Rosenbush is the blogs/industry editor for Portfolio.com.

Comments

If you are commenting using a Facebook account, your profile information may be displayed with your comment depending on your privacy settings. By leaving the 'Post to Facebook' box selected, your comment will be published to your Facebook profile in addition to the space below.

Connect With Portfolio.com

Come on, like us—you know you want to.

Follow us and if you're an innovative entrepreneur, we'll return the favor.

Today's top stories, conversation starters, and the back nine business bites.

spotlight on

Slideshows

500 Startups Hits New York

Dave McClure's brainchild makes its way to New York and introduces East Coast money folks to some intriguing new companies. View Slideshow